loading loading
Eastman Johnson Catalogue Raisonné
Patricia Hills, PhD, Founder and Director | Abigael MacGibeny, Project Manager and Co-Author

Catalogue Entry

enlarge
Photo: Bruce Museum, Greenwich, CT
Three Studies for The Counterfeiters, c.1851–55 (Hills no. 1.0.10). Overall
Overall
Photo: Patricia Hills
Three Studies for The Counterfeiters, c.1851–55 (Hills no. 1.0.10). Detail
Detail
Photo: Patricia Hills
Three Studies for The Counterfeiters, c.1851–55 (Hills no. 1.0.10). Detail
Detail
Photo: Patricia Hills
Three Studies for The Counterfeiters, c.1851–55 (Hills no. 1.0.10). Detail
Detail
Photo: Patricia Hills
Three Studies for The Counterfeiters, c.1851–55 (Hills no. 1.0.10). Inscription
Inscription
Photo: Patricia Hills
01.0 Euro Genre

By the summer of 1849, Johnson resolved to go to Europe with his friend George Hall. Although he reputedly was earning a good living with his portrait drawings, figure and genre painting attracted him and first-rate instruction in these fields was not available in the United States. Moreover, both artists realized the importance of studying the European masters at first hand. Hall and Johnson were coaxed into choosing Düsseldorf by the American Art-Union, the most important organ of artistic patronage in America in the 1840s. To raise funds for his travel, Johnson sold two drawings to the AAU and was also assured by Andrew Warner of the AAU that the organization would accept future works by him. Johnson and Hall sailed from New York on August 14, 1849, for Europe. He took classes at the Royal Academy in Düsseldorf, but records of his exact attendance are not known. He felt skilled enough by October 1950 to send two oils to the NAD for sale. In a letter accompanying the shipment he admitted he was sending the pictures “rather earlier in my practice of oils than I should otherwise do.” The two pictures, Peasants on the Rhine and The Junior Partner are long since lost. The majority of his genre paintings were done in the Netherlands, after he moved to the Hague in 1851
[Adapted from Hills, The Genre Painting of Eastman Johnson, pp. 27–32]. —PH

View all works in this theme »

Hills no. 1.0.10
1907 Sale no. 25
Three Studies for The Counterfeiters
1907 Sale title: Three Studies for One of The Counterfeiters
Alternate titles: Study for "The Counterfeiters"; The Counterfeiters; The Counterfeiters (study); Three Heads of One of the Counterfiters [sic]; Three Studies of Talmudic Scholars
c.1851–55
Oil on canvas
16 x 15 in. (40.6 x 38.1 cm)
Initialed lower left, not in Johnson's hand: E.J.
This catalogue raisonné strives to reproduce the available historical information, as it was written in the period, while acknowledging that readers today may find many of these terms objectionable or racist. Please see the Racist Language/Negative Stereotypes Statement »
Description/Remarks

Hills, 2021: Note that the figure at the upper left is different from the figure in the center and the figure on the right, which are studies of the same person.

Although John I. H. Baur owned and annotated a copy of the catalogue of Johnson's 1907 Estate Sale, he did not include this work in his own 1940 catalogue listing; he must have obtained it after publication.

1907 Estate Sale info
No. 25: "Two heads and a half-length study of one of the principal figures in the picture entitled 'The Counterfeiters.' The two heads are from the same sitter, who is apparently a Jew of rather low type."
"Height, 15 ¼ inches; width, 14 ½ inches"
[Annotation: “30.00”]

Markings
Label on verso: American Art Gallery $25.00

Label on verso: 16 x 15
Provenance
Eastman Johnson estate/Mrs. Eastman Johnson, New York, 1906 (by bequest)
[The artist's estate sale, American Art Association, New York, February 26–27, 1907, no. 25 (as Three Studies for One of The Counterfeiters)]
[American Art Galleries, New York]
Albert L. Hassis, New Haven, Connecticut
[Savoy Art & Auction Galleries, New York]
[Unidentified auction house, January 31, 1948, lot 81 (as Three Studies of Talmudic Scholars)]
Private collection, by April 7, 1971
[Sotheby's, March 14, 1996, lot 50 (as Three Studies for One of the Counterfeiters)]
Mr. and Mrs. Stuart P. Feld, New York, March 14, 1996 (by purchase)
[Shannon's Fine Art Auctioneers, Milford, Connecticut, April 24, 2003, Sale 042403, lot 154 (as The Counterfeiters)]
Bruce Museum, Greenwich, Connecticut, April 24, 2003 (by purchase)
Exhibitions
1907a Century Association
Century Association, New York, Memorial Exhibition of Eastman Johnson, February 9–13, 1907, as Three Heads of One of the Counterfiters [sic].
2011 Bruce Museum
Bruce Museum, Greenwich, Connecticut, Human Connections: Figural Art from the Bruce Museum Collections, February 11–June 5, 2011.
2017 Bruce Museum
Bruce Museum, Greenwich, Connecticut, Canvas and Cast: Highlights from the Bruce Museum’s Art Collection, February 11–September 3, 2017.
References
AAA 1907b
Catalogue of Finished Pictures, Studies, and Drawings by the Late Eastman Johnson, N.A. New York: American Art Association, February 1907. Sale catalogue, n.p., no. 25, as Three Studies for One of The Counterfeiters.
Douglass 1999
Douglass, Julie M. "Lifetime Exhibition History." In Eastman Johnson: Painting America, by Teresa A. Carbone and Patricia Hills. Brooklyn, NY: Brooklyn Museum of Art, in association with Rizzoli International Publications, 1999. Exhibition catalogue, p. 266, as Three Heads of One of the Counterfiters [sic].
Wallach 2022
Wallach, Alan. "Eastman Johnson's Jews." Perspectives on Eastman Johnson, National Academy of Design (New York), February 15, 2022, as Three Studies for The Counterfeiters.
Hills Examination/Opinion
Examination date(s): 1996-03-09; 2018-08-06
Examination notes: Hills 2018: Oil on canvas, very flat, was relined. Although a study, the faces are very finished. One character is represented once, the two right faces show the same person but different views. Beautiful painting, Rembrandtesque with broad highlights on foreheads. Very much EJ's European style. Brown sienna background. Grey-blue highlights on lips, top of chin, eyes. Patches of color on faces; ruddy cheeks.
Hills opinion letter: March 13, 1996 view »
Related work
loading
Record last updated January 30, 2025. Please note that the information on this and all pages is periodically reviewed and subject to change.
Citation: Hills, Patricia, and Abigael MacGibeny. "Three Studies for The Counterfeiters, c.1851–55 (Hills no. 1.0.10)." In Eastman Johnson Catalogue Raisonné. www.eastmanjohnson.org/catalogue/entry.php?id=12 (accessed on May 1, 2025).